Trying to pull an emotion from the depths of yourself while singing an aria can feel unreliable, like trying to grasp running water.
Emotions flow through us naturally in everyday life. We rarely think about summoning a particular feeling in the moment. But when we step onto a stage, something changes. Suddenly, there is pressure to perform, to communicate, and to show the audience everything we are feeling.
Paradoxically, this pressure can be exactly what gets in our way.
Music certainly moves us. It can evoke powerful feelings in both the performer and the listener. But listen to the same piece on different days, in different circumstances, and you might experience it differently each time. That doesn't necessarily mean the intention behind the music has changed. It simply means that your own feelings have shifted.
So you've learned the notes, the rhythms, and the text. You have an understanding of the character and the context of the piece. Perhaps you've thought about the emotions it evokes in you and how you want the audience to feel.
But how do you translate all of that into a performance?
Do you ever step onto the stage knowing exactly what you want the audience to feel, yet struggle to communicate it? Perhaps your teacher asks you what your character is feeling, and you know the answer perfectly well, but you don't know how to make that feeling come across.
Or perhaps you find yourself freezing up, thinking only about your technique, the words, or the possibility of making a mistake.
What does it actually mean to act through music?
Intention Before Emotion
I keep coming back to the idea that, in everyday life, we don't go around thinking about what emotions we want to feel. We have intentions. We want something, we do something to get it, and we encounter obstacles along the way. Sometimes we succeed, and sometimes we don't.
We are constantly acting, even when we aren't consciously thinking about it.
What if we approached music in the same way?
Music is not something we have to fill with emotion. It is something active with intentions we can pursue.
The feelings that arise are part of the beauty of performance, but they aren't always predictable or repeatable. We can't reliably build a technique around trying to summon the same emotion every time we perform a piece. We can, however, work with intention.
This is the idea that sits at the heart of my approach to acting for musicians: rather than beginning with the question of what a character feels, begin by asking what a character is trying to do.
Are they trying to persuade someone? To provoke a reaction? To conceal something? To reassure, seduce, challenge, or convince?
These are actions. They give us something concrete to work with, something we can practise and return to each time we approach a piece.
The Active Score
The idea of action as a foundation for acting is central to Konstantin Stanislavski's work, presented in his book An Actor Prepares. His approach has influenced generations of actors, and I became interested in how these ideas could be further adapted for singing.
During my master's research at the Royal Conservatoire The Hague, I explored ways of translating action-based acting techniques into a practical method for singers. This included working with action verbs, improvisation, and the musical score itself.
I call this approach the Active Score.
The idea is to mark the score with specific actions and intentions, giving yourself something to play throughout the music. Rather than simply noting that a phrase is sad, angry, or joyful, you might write I challenge, I plead, or I convince you.
One resource I recommend to students is The Actor's Thesaurus, a book highly regarded and utilized in acting pedagogy. It contains a wide range of action verbs that can help you find more specific ways to approach a scene or a musical phrase.
Find An Actor Prepares here.
Find Actions: The Actor's Thesaurus here.
Because we aren't necessarily used to thinking in terms of action verbs when we practise music, this approach can feel unfamiliar at first. It takes time to develop the skill. I find it helpful to write intentions directly into the score and practise them as deliberately as I would practise a difficult coloratura passage or a challenging piano fingering.
And just like any other aspect of musical preparation, the work can change over time.
Intentions are personal. An action that works for one performer might not work for another. Something that feels right one month might feel completely different when you return to the piece later.
That's part of the process. You can adjust your choices, experiment with different actions, and surprise yourself. The goal isn't to lock yourself into one interpretation forever. It's to give yourself a practical way into the music.
Putting It Into Practice: Ach, ich fühl's
Recently, I was preparing for a recording session of Pamina's aria Ach, ich fühl's from Mozart's Die Zaubeflöte
I find this aria particularly tempting to approach through its emotions. Pamina feels alone, heartbroken, and terrified that she has lost Tamino's love. It's tempting to focus entirely on communicating those feelings.
But Pamina isn't simply experiencing heartbreak. She is also trying to affect someone else.
Her objective gave me a way forward.
In preparation for this recording session, I took out my score and began experimenting with action verbs.
The opening piano chords felt like a shock to me, so I marked the score with I shock. When Pamina begins to question whether her happiness is gone forever, I used I question. As she repeats the thought that her love and happiness are lost, I marked I cry out.
In the next piano interjection, I felt a sharp realisation. Above it, I wrote I absorb. I tried to imagine what it meant to absorb the thought that those hours of bliss would never return, allowing the realization to land rather than rushing past it.
When Pamina sings about her heart, I imagined the sensation of something closing tightly around it with I sensationalize. And during the rising coloratura, I began to search intently for that lost feeling, reaching for something I couldn't recover.
As I continued through the aria, I looked for more opportunities to give myself an action rather than simply describing Pamina's emotional state. I began to think about what she was doing to Tamino, what she was trying to understand, and how her intentions shifted throughout the music.
These choices weren't intended to establish the one correct interpretation of the aria. They were a way of making the music more active for me, giving me something to pursue rather than something I had to feel.
Try It For Yourself
You don't need to be an opera singer or actor to experiment with the Active Score. You can try it with any song, an instrumental passage, or even a short musical phrase.
1. Choose a short phrase. Pick something you know well enough that you can focus on more than the notes.
2. Identify an intention. What are you trying to communicate or accomplish? If the music has a text, consider what the character wants from the person they're addressing. If it's instrumental, think about what the musical gesture is doing.
3. Choose an action verb. Try something specific, such as to challenge, to persuade, to reassure, or to provoke.
4. Perform the phrase with that action in mind. Don't force a particular emotion. Focus on carrying out the action.
5. Try a contrasting verb. Repeat the phrase with a different intention. Notice what changes in your timing, articulation, sound, physicality, or attention.
You might find that one action immediately makes sense, while another feels awkward or unconvincing. Both responses can be useful. Experiment, and give yourself permission to change your mind.
I've included a [PDF worksheet of action verbs here] to help you get started.
The Active Score is an ongoing practice, not a formula for producing a perfect performance. It's a way of giving yourself something to do in the music, something you can return to when you feel stuck, distracted, or unsure how to communicate what you hear and understand.
In my next post, I'll look more closely at how I mark up a musical score and turn these ideas into a practical rehearsal tool.
If you'd like to follow along, you can sign up for email updates below.
Want to explore this in your own music?
I offer one-on-one coaching for singers and musicians who want to develop their approach to acting and expression in performance. If you'd like to explore the Active Score in your own work, you can find out more about my coaching here.